Trial DataTrek Morning Briefings for Free

Thousands of investors and financial journalists rely on Nick and Jessica’s newsletter every day for their thought-provoking work on markets, data and disruption. See why for yourself by starting a 2-week FREE trial below.


S&P 500 Recessionary Earnings Power

By admin_45 in Blog S&P 500 Recessionary Earnings Power

What if the global economy entered a recession in the first half of 2018? Very few analysts expect such an outcome, but that alone makes it a question worth pondering. How would US corporate profits, and by extension stock prices, fare in a typical recession?

We went back to the late 1980s and looked at corporate earnings power for the S&P 500 during past recessions. Here is what we found, using 4 quarter trailing operating earnings:

  • Late 80s/early 1990s: S&P 500 earnings peaked in Q2 1989 at $25.53/share and troughed in Q4 1991 at $19.30/share. Net decline: 24.4% over 10 quarters.
  • Early 2000s: peak earnings in Q3 2000 at $56.79/share, which fell to a low of $38.85/share in Q4 2001. Net decline: 31.6% over 5 quarters.
  • 2008 Financial Crisis: peak earnings in Q2 2007 at $91.47/share, falling to $39.61/share in Q3 2009. Net decline: 56.7% over 9 quarters.

The math here shows that a “Typical” recession (albeit caused by large scale geopolitical events in both 1990 and 2001) creates a 25-30% decline in S&P 500 earnings. With current 4-quarter trailing S&P earnings of $119/share, that would put the next trough at $83 – $89/share.

With the index trading at 2,600, that makes the S&P 500 valued at 29-31x future “Trough” earnings. Is that cheap or expensive? A little more history frames the discussion:

  • In June 1989 (the peak of that cycle for earnings), the S&P 500 was trading for 16.5x its eventual trough operating earnings (the 4 quarters ending Q4 1991).
  • In September 2000 (again the peak), the S&P 500 traded for 37x the eventual earnings trough in Q4 2001.
  • In June 2007 (peak pre-Crisis earnings), the S&P 500 traded for 38x the very low earnings of Q3 2009 (including the index’s only ever negative quarterly earnings).

The conclusion: even at current all-time high levels the S&P 500 is notionally cheap (29-31x) to prior “Peak” periods like 2000 (37x) and 2007 (38x), but not likely cheap enough to buffer equity prices in the case of a sudden and unexpected recession. The S&P took 7 years to get back to 1,500 after the 2000 highs, and 6 years to regain that same level after 2007. It takes much lower valuations, like the 1989 experience, to allow the index to recover in less than a year.

Bottom line: US equity markets are pricing in essentially zero probability of a 2018 recession. Options markets, as we discussed recently, are largely in the same boat. Fair enough for now - nothing in the geopolitical pot seems to be nearing a boil. And the world’s central banks remain in low-interest rate mode. But make no mistake: the S&P 500 is priced only for further earnings growth.

Trial DataTrek Morning Briefings for Free

Thousands of investors and financial journalists rely on Nick and Jessica’s newsletter every day for their thought-provoking work on markets, data and disruption. See why for yourself by starting a 2-week FREE trial below.