Trial DataTrek Morning Briefings for Free

Thousands of investors and financial journalists rely on Nick and Jessica’s newsletter every day for their thought-provoking work on markets, data and disruption. See why for yourself by starting a 2-week FREE trial below.


US State/City Unemployment: Dramatic Differences

By admin_45 in Blog US State/City Unemployment: Dramatic Differences

The latest US state- and city-level unemployment data was out today; here are 3 points to consider:

#1: Although the national unemployment rate declined in September to 7.9 percent from 8.4 percent in August, the improvement was not spread evenly around the country. Here are the month-to-month differences for the 15 most populous US states (where two thirds of the American population live).

Large states that saw increases in unemployment from August to September 2020:

  • Texas: 6.8 percent (August) to 8.3 percent (September)
  • Florida: 7.4 pct to 7.6 pct
  • Georgia: 5.6 pct to 6.4 pct
  • North Carolina: 6.5 pct to 7.3 pct
  • Virginia: 6.1 pct to 6.2 pct
  • Arizona: 5.9 pct to 6.7 pct
  • Average unemployment, August and September: 6.4 percent and 7.1 percent
  • Average increase in unemployment: 0.7 points

Large states that saw decreases from August to September 2020:

  • California: 11.4 percent (August) to 11.0 percent (September)
  • New York: 12.5 pct to 9.6 pct
  • Pennsylvania: 10.3 pct to 8.1 pct
  • Illinois: 11.0 pct to 10.2 pct
  • Ohio: 8.9 pct to 8.4 pct
  • Michigan: 8.7 pct to 8.5 pct
  • New Jersey: 10.9 pct to 6.7 pct
  • Washington: 8.5 pct to 7.8 pct
  • Massachusetts: 11.3 pct to 9.6 pct
  • Average unemployment, August and September: 10.4 percent and 8.9 percent
  • Average decrease in unemployment: 1.5 points

Takeaway: September’s lower national unemployment rate was due to a decline in joblessness in populous states that were most hard-hit by this spring/summer’s shutdowns. Conversely, the headwinds came from states which reopened more quickly but could not sustain quick improvements in their labor markets. From this short-term data set it does seem like the US has a structural unemployment rate of 7 percent on the low end (the first cluster of states mentioned) and 9 percent (the second cluster). Future months may shade that to 6 – 8 percent if labor markets can improve, but we’re a long way from 2019’s 3 – 4 percent.

#2: Urban centers are still seeing very high levels of unemployment, even if these are slowly improving. The data here is still coming in, but we do have information for the 3 largest US cities:

New York City: 14.1 percent in September, down from 16.0 percent in August and a June peak of 20.3 percent.

Los Angeles: 15.1 percent in September, down from 16.8 percent in August and a May peak of 20.8 percent.

Chicago: 11.3 percent in September, down from 12.7 percent in August and a June peak of 16.3 percent.

Worth noting: there are 1.7 million unemployed workers in just these 3 cities. That is 13.5 percent of all jobless Americans, even though the populations of New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago only make up 4.6 percent of the US population.

Takeaway: urban labor markets face the toughest slog until there is a vaccine, and since 14 percent of all unemployed Americans live in NYC, LA and Chicago we can see joblessness in these cities remaining well above national levels into mid-2021.

#3: For readers with an interest in US politics, here are the recent unemployment trends for some commonly cited Presidential election swing states:

As mentioned above, these swing states saw an increase in unemployment last month:

  • Texas
  • Florida
  • Georgia
  • North Carolina
  • Arizona

These swing states, however, had better employment trends in September:

  • Ohio
  • Pennsylvania
  • Michigan
  • Iowa (6.0 percent in August, 4.7 percent in September)
  • Maine (6.9 percent, 6.1 percent)
  • Minnesota (7.4 pct, 6.0 pct)
  • Nevada (13.2 pct, 12.6)
  • New Hampshire (6.5 pct, 6.0 pct)
  • Wisconsin (6.2 pct, 5.4 pct)

Takeaway: in any other Presidential election year we would say marginal changes in unemployment would weigh heavily on state-level outcomes, and perhaps it is wrong to think it is any different in 2020. We keep coming back to the fact that online prediction/gambling odds for Trump vs. Biden remain fairly close (40/60 or so) and the setup we’ve outlined in this point shows why the race really is too close to call definitively.

Trial DataTrek Morning Briefings for Free

Thousands of investors and financial journalists rely on Nick and Jessica’s newsletter every day for their thought-provoking work on markets, data and disruption. See why for yourself by starting a 2-week FREE trial below.